Rephonic
Artwork for Ice Cold Case

Ice Cold Case

Madison McGhee
Belmont County
Daryl Smith
Belmont County Sheriff's Department
JC Mcgee
Madison Mcghee
Omar
Murder
Murder Mystery
Omar Foster
Rico Mcgee
911 Calls
Bridgeport Police Department
Home Invasion
Investigative Methods
Alyssa
Unsolved Crimes
Cold Cases
Murder Investigation
Detective Aller
Detective Duvall

In 2002, my dad was murdered in the doorway of his home. Now, I am ready to find answers to the coldest case in Belmont County, Ohio. This is the story of a daughter desperate for justice, for closure, for someone to care. It doesn't get more personal than this.

PublishesWeeklyEpisodes40Founded3 years ago
Number of ListenersCategories
Personal JournalsTrue CrimeSociety & Culture

Listen to this Podcast

Artwork for Ice Cold Case

Latest Episodes

Someone with a very close connection to Omar comes forward with what he said privately about July 11, 2002. This new version of the story contradicts timelines and raises new questions about fear, power, and what never made it into the case files.

00... more

In a conversation with the key witness, Omar Foston, there's new claims and contradictions about the hours surrounding J.C. McGhee's murder. A revealing phone call shines light on the uncomfortable possibility that the truth, and the killer, might be... more

Josh Mankiewicz (NBC's Dateline) is back on the pod! Josh joins Madison McGhee for a live conversation from Denver, Colorado (CrimeCon 2025) about the updates in the case of the murder of J.C. McGhee, how life has changed since she started this journ... more

YouTube

A breakdown of the DNA, ballistics, and forensic evidence that could finally solve J.C. McGhee's case. Questioning what evidence exists and why the Belmont County Sheriff’s Department won't test it.

00:00 - Previously On

01:06 - Part 0: From Guessi... more

YouTube

Key Facts

Accepts Sponsors
Contact Information
Podcast Host
Number of Listeners
Find out how many people listen to this podcast per episode and each month.

Similar Podcasts

People also subscribe to these shows.

Recent Guests

Ego Nwodim
Comedian known for her work on Saturday Night Live
Saturday Night Live
Episode: You May Also Like: Petty Crimes
Rico McGhee
A real smart, intelligent individual implicated in the case investigation.
Episode: Bad Cops. Bad Neighbors.
David Lucas
Former Sheriff of Belmont County, served from 2012 to 2025.
Belmont County Sheriff's Department
Episode: Bad Cops. Bad Neighbors.
Fred Thompson
Former Sheriff of Belmont County, served from 2004 to 2013.
Belmont County Sheriff's Department
Episode: Bad Cops. Bad Neighbors.
Paul Weir-Gartner
Retired FBI agent with vast experience in criminal investigations.
Episode: Bad Cops. Bad Neighbors.
Celisia Stanton
Host and creator of Truer Crime, known for exploring a wide range of cases with a unique perspective.
Truer Crime
Episode: Bonus: Truer Crime (with Celisia Stanton)
Omar Foster
Witness and neighbor to the victim, involved in the call to 911
Episode: Between the Lines
Jill Templin
Daryl's ex-girlfriend who provides an alibi for him during the time of the murder.
Episode: Killer Eyes
Daryl Smith
Main suspect in the murder of John Cornelius McGee
Episode: Back to Belmont County

Host

Madison McGhee
Host and storyteller dedicated to seeking justice for her father's unsolved murder and sharing her personal journey.

Reviews

4.6 out of 5 stars from 1.5k ratings
  • Powerful podcast

    So powerful- I hope she finds the answers. All should share.

    Apple Podcasts
    5
    pgrabin1
    United States17 days ago
  • The bestest

    No doubt she has the most soothing voice in the game. I can listen to her for hours!! This is something you can listen to anywhere at anytime like on a long car ride, the shower or even at a boring wedding fr fr.

    Apple Podcasts
    5
    camteriyaki
    United Statesa month ago
  • 10/10!

    This podcast is exactly what the true crime genre needed. I am so glad Madison is telling her own story through such a well-made podcast. It’s a surprisingly fresh take. This stands out amongst the rest! Don’t skip out on this. Very unique voice.

    Apple Podcasts
    5
    ryro56
    United Statesa month ago
  • Started well….

    First episodes were good but now she’s just reaching for content. Taping everyone she talks to (and investigators who have specifically asked not to be on the podcast) then disregarding that and putting recordings on, then wonders why ‘the police have something’ and won’t tell her.

    Apple Podcasts
    3
    Quick Quokka
    Australiaa month ago
  • No notes!

    You’re going to solve this!! And then move on to other cases! You have such a talent for investigating and telling the tragedy like a well written story. Keep it up girl!

    Apple Podcasts
    5
    Saltybae13
    United Statesa month ago

Listeners Say

Key themes from listener reviews, highlighting what works and what could be improved about the show.

Listeners appreciate the raw and emotional storytelling that keeps them on the edge of their seats.
There is significant praise for the personal depth and authenticity that the host brings to the narrative, making it relatable to many.
Some critiques mention repetitiveness in certain episodes, suggesting a desire for more structured storytelling.
The podcast is often described as gripping, with many listeners expressing anticipation for future episodes and updates on ongoing cases.

Chart Rankings

How this podcast ranks in the Apple Podcasts, Spotify and YouTube charts.

Apple Podcasts
#200
Belgium/True Crime
Apple Podcasts
#207
Colombia/True Crime

Talking Points

Recent interactions between the hosts and their guests.

Omar's Side
Q: Would any family members have been involved in your dad's murder?
Omar indicates that family connections exist among potential suspects but does not provide specific involvement.
Omar's Side
Q: How do you think the cops were involved based on your experience that day?
Omar suggests there were two cops involved and alleges that they had informants connected to the crime.
Bonus: Crime Weekly Full Interview (Part 1)
Q: Can you talk just a little bit about your dad's role as a confidential informant?
It was for a case where he had to testify in court. My dad took the deal because he had custody of my sister, which influenced his decision.
Bonus: Crime Weekly Full Interview (Part 1)
Q: Can you talk about just a little bit about your family?
My dad had other children with other women, and there's rumors that he had two children when he was very young. My dad was quite the ladies' man.
Bonus: Crime Weekly Full Interview (Part 1)
Q: As you've done the podcast, have you come to know way more about your dad and just learned about who he was fully as a person?
Yes, in ways that maybe no one should learn about their parent. I've learned so much about my dad in the sense that he almost feels more like a friend than a parent.

Audience Metrics

Listeners, social reach, demographics and more for this podcast.

Listeners per Episode
Gender Skew
Location
Interests
Professions
Age Range
Household Income
Social Media Reach

Frequently Asked Questions About Ice Cold Case

What is Ice Cold Case about and what kind of topics does it cover?

This podcast focuses on a daughter's emotional journey as she investigates her father's unsolved murder, which occurred in 2002. The host shares intimate reflections and updates on her quest for justice, detailing the struggles of balancing her personal life with her dedication to uncover the truth. Each episode combines elements of true crime storytelling with personal insights, creating a rich narrative that resonates deeply with listeners. The exploration of family trauma, generational issues, and systemic failures within law enforcement set this podcast apart, offering a supportive community feel for those also seeking closure in their personal stories.

Notably, the content often merges investigative journalism with candid accounts of... more

Where can I find podcast stats for Ice Cold Case?

Rephonic provides a wide range of podcast stats for Ice Cold Case. We scanned the web and collated all of the information that we could find in our comprehensive podcast database. See how many people listen to Ice Cold Case and access YouTube viewership numbers, download stats, audience demographics, chart rankings, ratings, reviews and more.

How many listeners does Ice Cold Case get?

Rephonic provides a full set of podcast information for three million podcasts, including the number of listeners. View further listenership figures for Ice Cold Case, including podcast download numbers and subscriber numbers, so you can make better decisions about which podcasts to sponsor or be a guest on. You will need to upgrade your account to access this premium data.

What are the audience demographics for Ice Cold Case?

Rephonic provides comprehensive predictive audience data for Ice Cold Case, including gender skew, age, country, political leaning, income, professions, education level, and interests. You can access these listener demographics by upgrading your account.

How many subscribers and views does Ice Cold Case have?

To see how many followers or subscribers Ice Cold Case has on Spotify and other platforms such as Castbox and Podcast Addict, simply upgrade your account. You'll also find viewership figures for their YouTube channel if they have one.

Which podcasts are similar to Ice Cold Case?

These podcasts share a similar audience with Ice Cold Case:

1. Hell and Gone
2. Voices for Justice
3. Up and Vanished Weekly
4. Up and Vanished
5. Dakota Spotlight: True Crime & Cold Case Investigations

How many episodes of Ice Cold Case are there?

Ice Cold Case launched 3 years ago and published 40 episodes to date. You can find more information about this podcast including rankings, audience demographics and engagement in our podcast database.

How do I contact Ice Cold Case?

Our systems regularly scour the web to find email addresses and social media links for this podcast. We scanned the web and collated all of the contact information that we could find in our podcast database. But in the unlikely event that you can't find what you're looking for, our concierge service lets you request our research team to source better contacts for you.

Where can I see ratings and reviews for Ice Cold Case?

Rephonic pulls ratings and reviews for Ice Cold Case from multiple sources, including Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Castbox, and Podcast Addict.

View all the reviews in one place instead of visiting each platform individually and use this information to decide if a show is worth pitching or not.

How do I access podcast episode transcripts for Ice Cold Case?

Rephonic provides full transcripts for episodes of Ice Cold Case. Search within each transcript for your keywords, whether they be topics, brands or people, and figure out if it's worth pitching as a guest or sponsor. You can even set-up alerts to get notified when your keywords are mentioned.

What guests have appeared on Ice Cold Case?

Recent guests on Ice Cold Case include:

1. Ego Nwodim
2. Rico McGhee
3. David Lucas
4. Fred Thompson
5. Paul Weir-Gartner
6. Celisia Stanton
7. Omar Foster
8. Jill Templin

To view more recent guests and their details, simply upgrade your Rephonic account. You'll also get access to a typical guest profile to help you decide if the show is worth pitching.

Find and pitch the right podcasts

We help savvy brands, marketers and PR professionals to find the right podcasts for any topic or niche. Get the data and contacts you need to pitch podcasts at scale and turn listeners into customers.
Try it free for 7 days