
Everything Scary is a podcast that delves into all things spine-chilling. While it primarily focuses on true crime, it also covers anything else that falls under the umbrella of fear. For those listeners who HATE banter, this may not be the pod for you. We try to dial it back, since it does not appeal to everyone. But, it does still get away from us sometimes. The hosts approach these serious top... more
| Publishes | Twice weekly | Episodes | 207 | Founded | 4 years ago |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Number of Listeners | Categories | ComedyTrue Crime | |||

Send a text
In 1987 the world held its breath for 58 hours, after an 18 month old child had fallen down an 8 inch abandoned well, in her aunts back yard. To this day if you hear 'baby Jessica' most know what this is in reference to, and has even bee... more
Send a text
This episode is a mash up of a few topics- Matt answers a 'Whats the Matt'r' question, plus some Olympic women's hockey news, we also touch on the new studio and the reasoning behind it.
We also discuss the 1995 disappearance of 6 year ... more
Send a text
On May 11 2022, while in Texas, staying with a friend, as she awaited a 155 mile bike race. 23-year old Moriah Wilson was shot to death, in the home of her friend Caitlyn Cash. Originally, authorities suspected, the last person Mo was kn... more
Send a text
On this special episode, Matt tells us all about the most romantic celebrity couples of all time (not really) and he also uses his expertise to answer a...very interesting What's The Matt'r question.
Support the show
If you’re interes... more
People also subscribe to these shows.





This week’s episode had 38 minutes of nonsensical banter (about diarrhoea) before they actually started discussing the case.
really annoying cohost says nothing and laughs too much
This isn’t a review. This is a warning carved into the inside of my skull before I forget my own name. Everything Scary is not a podcast. It’s the thing pretending to be a podcast so you’ll let it in. The voices are not voices. They’re coordinates disguised as anecdotes, instructions hidden in the spaces between words. Every laugh track is a key. Every intro jingle is a door. If you’ve listened, you’ve already opened it. They tell you about ghosts. You start seeing the same numbers in receipts, ... more
20 minutes of irrelevant talking before starting the podcast episode. Tattoo savings yourselves before recording (!?) 5 minutes later I turned it off because I cannot stand how he constantly interrupts her.
From having a mental breakdown because of female hormones in the morning and then listening to you guys on my way to work, saved my day. You are my all time therapy. And when Matt did his german take on the Hitler thing, that was full circle for me.
Key themes from listener reviews, highlighting what works and what could be improved about the show.










Recent interactions between the hosts and their guests.
Listeners, social reach, demographics and more for this podcast.
| Listeners per Episode | |
|---|---|
| Gender Skew | |
| Location | |
| Interests | |
| Professions | |
| Age Range | |
| Household Income | |
| Social Media Reach |
Everything Scary blends true crime deep-dives with lighthearted banter, creating a distinctive balance between respect for victims and entertaining, personality-driven storytelling. Episodes tend to pair meticulous case details with playful host dynamics, tangents, and cultural commentary, which helps keep dense cases engaging for a broader audience. The show covers a wide range of cases—from well-known tragedies to historical mysteries—and often weaves in media analysis, social issues, and audience interaction. A notable strength is the duo's chemistry and their ability to maintain humor without diminishing the gravity of the subjects, which likely appeals to listeners who want thoughtful storytelling with a lighter vibe. The format also i... more
Rephonic provides a wide range of podcast stats for Everything Scary. We scanned the web and collated all of the information that we could find in our comprehensive podcast database. See how many people listen to Everything Scary and access YouTube viewership numbers, download stats, audience demographics, chart rankings, ratings, reviews and more.
Rephonic provides a full set of podcast information for three million podcasts, including the number of listeners. View further listenership figures for Everything Scary, including podcast download numbers and subscriber numbers, so you can make better decisions about which podcasts to sponsor or be a guest on. You will need to upgrade your account to access this premium data.
Rephonic provides comprehensive predictive audience data for Everything Scary, including gender skew, age, country, political leaning, income, professions, education level, and interests. You can access these listener demographics by upgrading your account.
To see how many followers or subscribers Everything Scary has on Spotify and other platforms such as Castbox and Podcast Addict, simply upgrade your account. You'll also find viewership figures for their YouTube channel if they have one.
These podcasts share a similar audience with Everything Scary:
1. Moms and Mysteries: A True Crime Podcast
2. Big Mad True Crime
3. LOVE MURDER
4. Generation Why: True Crime
5. Murder In America
Everything Scary launched 4 years ago and published 207 episodes to date. You can find more information about this podcast including rankings, audience demographics and engagement in our podcast database.
Our systems regularly scour the web to find email addresses and social media links for this podcast. We scanned the web and collated all of the contact information that we could find in our podcast database. But in the unlikely event that you can't find what you're looking for, our concierge service lets you request our research team to source better contacts for you.
Rephonic pulls ratings and reviews for Everything Scary from multiple sources, including Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Castbox, and Podcast Addict.
View all the reviews in one place instead of visiting each platform individually and use this information to decide if a show is worth pitching or not.
Rephonic provides full transcripts for episodes of Everything Scary. Search within each transcript for your keywords, whether they be topics, brands or people, and figure out if it's worth pitching as a guest or sponsor. You can even set-up alerts to get notified when your keywords are mentioned.
Recent guests on Everything Scary include:
1. Michael Chorney
2. Dan Brown Jr.
To view more recent guests and their details, simply upgrade your Rephonic account. You'll also get access to a typical guest profile to help you decide if the show is worth pitching.