Rephonic
Artwork for Finding Nancy: The Nancy Guthrie Investigation

Finding Nancy: The Nancy Guthrie Investigation

Hidden Killers Podcast
Nancy Guthrie
FBI
Chris Nanos
Nancy Guthrie Case
Sheriff Chris Nanos
Nancy Guthrie Investigation
Tucson
Savannah Guthrie
Tucson, United States
DNA
Wrench Attack
Pima County
Pima County Sheriff's Department
Federal Bureau Of Investigation
Defamation
Bitcoin
Ransom
Ransom Notes
Delphi Case
Felony Murder

An 84-year-old woman vanishes from her Tucson home. No witnesses. No ransom call that makes sense. And a family waiting in the kind of silence that breaks people.

Nancy Guthrie—mother of Today Show anchor Savannah Guthrie—disappeared on January 24, 2025, setting off a national investigation that has exposed deep dysfunction between federal and local law enforcement, raised more questions than ans... more

PublishesDailyEpisodes130Founded5 months ago
Number of ListenersCategories
NewsNews CommentaryTrue Crime

Listen to this Podcast

Artwork for Finding Nancy: The Nancy Guthrie Investigation

Latest Episodes

Five months after Nancy Guthrie was kidnapped from her home, a detail that had been kept private was finally made public. A second note sent to a Tucson station days after the abduction claimed Nancy died shortly after she was taken. The senders expr... more

Five months after Nancy Guthrie was allegedly taken from her Tucson home, the sheriff leading the case went on local radio and said he thinks the FBI has made “a number of arrests” for fake ransom notes. He thinks. The lead investigator doesn’t know ... more

After a long stretch of silence, the Nancy Guthrie case got a surge of confidence from an unexpected place. On Megyn Kelly's show, retired FBI agent Maureen O'Connell said her sources tell her investigators are closing in on "porch guy," the masked m... more

Behind the headlines, the Nancy Guthrie case may be quietly stuck. Air Mail's Howard Blum reports that the investigators themselves fear an early mistake cost them their best chance to solve the abduction of the 84-year-old grandmother. Suspects repo... more

Key Facts

Accepts Guests
Contact Information
Podcast Host
Number of Listeners
Find out how many people listen to this podcast per episode and each month.

Similar Podcasts

People also subscribe to these shows.

Recent Guests

Jen Coffindaffer
Retired FBI Special Agent, discussed on the show
Former FBI, Behavioral Analyst
Episode: Where Is Nancy Guthrie? A Sheriff's Credibility Crisis and the Questions That Demand Answers
Eric Faddis
Defense attorney and former prosecutor
Private Practice
Episode: Nancy Guthrie Investigation: Command Center Moves, Task Force Scales Down, Innocent People Destroyed
Robin Dreeker
Retired FBI Special Agent, former Chief of the Counterintelligence Behavioral Analysis Program
FBI
Episode: Nancy Guthrie: The Night It Happened, the Questions Still Unanswered, and What Could Bring Her Home
Robin Dreeke
Retired FBI Special Agent, former Chief of the FBI's Counterintelligence Behavioral Analysis Program
FBI
Episode: Nancy Guthrie: 400 Investigators, No Arrests — Why the Case May Be Scaling Back
Jennifer Coffindaffer
Retired FBI Special Agent
FBI
Episode: Three Weeks, Three Detentions, Zero Arrests: Coffindaffer Assesses the Guthrie Case
Shavaun Scott
Psychotherapist and author
Independent/Behavioral Analyst
Episode: Nancy Guthrie: Psychotherapist Analyzes the Criminal Mind, the Chaos & the Family's Trauma
Bob Motta
Defense attorney
Defense Diaries
Episode: Nancy Guthrie Case: Defense Attorney Exposes the Investigation Mistakes That Will Haunt This Trial

Hosts

Tony Brueski
Host and commentator known for analytical crime discussion and investigative critique.
Robin Dreeke
Co-host; former FBI official and leader of behavioral analysis programs.

Reviews

3.8 out of 5 stars from 18 ratings
  • Possibly the worst ever true crime podcast.

    Zero context. Frantic voices. 100% speculation. I’d rather listen to my elderly mother speculate on what happened. Please stop and appologize for wasting everyone’s time

    Apple Podcasts
    1
    DocYoc
    United Statesa month ago
  • Informative

    Good podcast and informative. I was searching for the latest on the case and heard some new info.

    Apple Podcasts
    5
    Marie Smith 100
    United States3 months ago

Listeners Say

Key themes from listener reviews, highlighting what works and what could be improved about the show.

Daily updates keep the investigation current without guesswork.
Informative discussions that cut through sensationalism.
Expert guests elevate the analysis with credible insights.

Top True Crime Podcasts

Crime Junkie
Crime JunkieAudiochuck
Dateline NBC
Dateline NBCNBC News
Morbid
MorbidAsh Kelley & Alaina Urquhart
Love Trapped
Love TrappediHeartPodcasts and Glass Podcasts
Dr. Death
Dr. DeathAudible
20/20
20/20ABC News
Serialously with Annie Elise
Serialously with Annie EliseAnnie Elise & Audioboom Studios

Talking Points

Recent interactions between the hosts and their guests.

Nancy Guthrie: A Confession On Paper And Still No Arrest
Q: How important is the integrity of the crime scene and chain of custody in a case like this?
Crucial. The defense can exploit any irregularities in how evidence was collected or transferred between labs to challenge admissibility and impact the prosecution's ability to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
Nancy Guthrie: A Confession On Paper And Still No Arrest
Q: As a prosecutor, where do you begin building a homicide case without a body at the scene?
The discussion suggests that while there is no absolute legal requirement for a body, prosecutors must rely on circumstantial evidence, credible testimony, and strong legal theories like transferred intent or felony murder, all while ensuring the body, if found, is connected to the defendant beyond reasonable doubt.
What Two Piles Of Evidence Could Finally Break The Nancy Guthrie Case?
Q: Could advances in DNA technology and data fusion change the outcome years down the road?
Yes, experts believe that future capabilities in separating mixed DNA and integrating diverse data sources (vehicle data, cell data, surveillance) could yield breakthroughs, even if current methods are limited by the sample's complexity.
What Two Piles Of Evidence Could Finally Break The Nancy Guthrie Case?
Q: What is the likelihood that the motive was known from day one, and how does that shape the approach to the investigation?
The guest suggests that motive being known from the start is plausible but requires corroboration from multiple data points, including ransom notes, public statements, and investigative direction; the discussion emphasizes not taking ransom notes at face value and weighing them against life-proofs and FBI recommendations.
Nancy Guthrie: 41 Days Later, Her Family Is Still Waiting — and This Investigation Is Still Moving
Q: What is the presumed motive and how has the narrative evolved from initial statements to present understanding?
The motive has been described as a kidnapping from the start, with authorities indicating the possibility that the abduction went bad and there may be no proof of life; the discussion centers on whether early statements align with what actually occurred.

Audience Metrics

Listeners, social reach, demographics and more for this podcast.

Listeners per Episode
Gender Skew
Location
Interests
Professions
Age Range
Household Income
Social Media Reach

Frequently Asked Questions About This Podcast

What is This Podcast about and what kind of topics does it cover?

A daily-leaning true crime analysis show that dissects a high-profile missing-person case with a strong emphasis on investigative process, interagency dynamics, and accountability. The host-led format features expert guests—often former law enforcement, behavioral analysts, and legal professionals—who break down evidence, evaluate public statements, and critique investigative steps. Across episodes, listeners get rigorous, source-backed takes on jurisdictional tensions, media influence, and the path toward answers, not sensationalism. The show stands out for its forensic-style scrutiny, concrete investigative recommendations, and willingness to challenge official narratives. Potential listeners who want clear, expert perspectives on complex... more

Where can I find podcast stats for this podcast?

Rephonic provides a wide range of podcast stats for this podcast. We scanned the web and collated all of the information that we could find in our comprehensive podcast database. See how many people listen to this podcast and access YouTube viewership numbers, download stats, audience demographics, chart rankings, ratings, reviews and more.

How many listeners does this podcast get?

Rephonic provides a full set of podcast information for three million podcasts, including the number of listeners. View further listenership figures for this podcast, including podcast download numbers and subscriber numbers, so you can make better decisions about which podcasts to sponsor or be a guest on. You will need to upgrade your account to access this premium data.

What are the audience demographics for this podcast?

Rephonic provides comprehensive predictive audience data for this podcast, including gender skew, age, country, political leaning, income, professions, education level, and interests. You can access these listener demographics by upgrading your account.

How many subscribers and views does this podcast have?

To see how many followers or subscribers this podcast has on Spotify and other platforms such as Castbox and Podcast Addict, simply upgrade your account. You'll also find viewership figures for their YouTube channel if they have one.

How many episodes of this podcast are there?

this podcast launched 5 months ago and published 130 episodes to date. You can find more information about this podcast including rankings, audience demographics and engagement in our podcast database.

How do I contact this podcast?

Our systems regularly scour the web to find email addresses and social media links for this podcast. We scanned the web and collated all of the contact information that we could find in our podcast database. But in the unlikely event that you can't find what you're looking for, our concierge service lets you request our research team to source better contacts for you.

Where can I see ratings and reviews for this podcast?

Rephonic pulls ratings and reviews for this podcast from multiple sources, including Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Castbox, and Podcast Addict.

View all the reviews in one place instead of visiting each platform individually and use this information to decide if a show is worth pitching or not.

How do I access podcast episode transcripts for this podcast?

Rephonic provides full transcripts for episodes of this podcast. Search within each transcript for your keywords, whether they be topics, brands or people, and figure out if it's worth pitching as a guest or sponsor. You can even set-up alerts to get notified when your keywords are mentioned.

What guests have appeared on this podcast?

Recent guests on this podcast include:

1. Jen Coffindaffer
2. Eric Faddis
3. Robin Dreeker
4. Robin Dreeke
5. Jennifer Coffindaffer
6. Shavaun Scott
7. Bob Motta

To view more recent guests and their details, simply upgrade your Rephonic account. You'll also get access to a typical guest profile to help you decide if the show is worth pitching.

Find and pitch the right podcasts

We help savvy brands, marketers and PR professionals to find the right podcasts for any topic or niche. Get the data and contacts you need to pitch podcasts at scale and turn listeners into customers.
Try it free for 7 days