Midnight Society Rejects
Midnight Society RejectsJoin B.J. and Sarah each week as they toss the midnight dust into the fire and revisit the eerie world of Are You Afraid of the Dark? From Zeebo the Clown’s haunting giggle to the twisted grin of the Ghastly Grinner, they’re deep-diving into every tale that kept us up at night. Whether you’re a ‘90s kid reliving your goosebumps or just B.J. and Sarah’s moms (as always, thanks for your support!), t... more
| Publishes | Weekly | Episodes | 49 | Founded | a year ago |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Number of Listeners | Categories | After ShowsTV & Film | |||
Listen to this Podcast
Latest Episodes
Sarah and BJ break down “The Tale of the Room for Rent,” a tale as old as time: about how a pilot killed in combat in World War II returns from beyond the grave to haunt the man he believes killed him—and (even worse!) stole his girlfriend.
Join the... more
Join Sarah and B.J. for a fiery new episode filled with hometown lore, haunted fire stations, an unexpected PSA reminding kids that their parents love them, and one important lesson: never trust a fire ghost. (A sentence we never expected to write.) ... more
Sarah and B.J. are back…this time with villains! In one of the most iconic (and blue-goo-covered) episodes of Are You Afraid of the Dark?, middle school odd couple Ethan Wood and Hooper Piccalaro find themselves face-to-face with the Ghastly Grinner—... more
Join Sarah and B.J. as they confess their most “illegal” activities—from claw machine heists to the occasional sub-20% tip (allegedly). Along the way, they discuss the things they hated as kids but would probably love today, wonder why no one has hir... more
Recent Guests
Hosts
Reviews
- Awesome!
So nostalgic and entertaining! Love it!
Apple Podcasts5hollymegan07
United States10 months ago - Fantastic 90’s nostalgia
The Midnight Society Rejects is the podcast I never knew I needed, but now don’t know what I’d do without!
As a millennial 90’s kid raised on SNICK and a lifelong enjoyment of spooky tales, getting to relive AYATD through these discussions is a wonderful curated trip down memory lane.
If you’re a fan of the original show, or cheesy horror, or even just the short story medium I highly recommend this podcast!
Love the Midwest vibe (Wisconsinite here) and references to 90’s childhood outside the... more
Apple Podcasts5SirMontyDadUnited Statesa year ago
Listeners Say
Key themes from listener reviews, highlighting what works and what could be improved about the show.
Chart Rankings
How this podcast ranks in the Apple Podcasts, Spotify and YouTube charts.
Apple Podcasts | #172 |  Germany/TV & Film/After Shows |
Audience Metrics
Listeners, social reach, demographics and more for this podcast.
| Listeners per Episode | Gender Skew | Location | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Interests | Professions | Age Range | |||
| Household Income | Social Media Reach | ||||
Frequently Asked Questions About Midnight Society Rejects
What is Midnight Society Rejects about and what kind of topics does it cover?
Two hosts, BJ Hollars and Sarah Chain Johnson, guide listeners through nostalgic, riff-heavy explorations of Are You Afraid of the Dark? stories. Episodes mix recap, cultural memory, and meta humor while unpacking production quirks, 90s tech and media references, and the series' recurring themes of family, fear, and memory. The banter leans into affectionate nostalgia, playful analysis, and fan-oriented trivia, making it appealing for longtime fans and curious newcomers who enjoy light, reunion-style discussions with personal storytelling woven in. A standout angle is the hosts' willingness to connect classic tales to broader cultural moments, and their chemistry and humor are consistent through diverse tale selections and guest mentions ac... more
Where can I find podcast stats for Midnight Society Rejects?
Rephonic provides a wide range of podcast stats for Midnight Society Rejects. We scanned the web and collated all of the information that we could find in our comprehensive podcast database. See how many people listen to Midnight Society Rejects and access YouTube viewership numbers, download stats, audience demographics, chart rankings, ratings, reviews and more.
How many listeners does Midnight Society Rejects get?
Rephonic provides a full set of podcast information for three million podcasts, including the number of listeners. View further listenership figures for Midnight Society Rejects, including podcast download numbers and subscriber numbers, so you can make better decisions about which podcasts to sponsor or be a guest on. You will need to upgrade your account to access this premium data.
What are the audience demographics for Midnight Society Rejects?
Rephonic provides comprehensive predictive audience data for Midnight Society Rejects, including gender skew, age, country, political leaning, income, professions, education level, and interests. You can access these listener demographics by upgrading your account.
How many subscribers and views does Midnight Society Rejects have?
To see how many followers or subscribers Midnight Society Rejects has on Spotify and other platforms such as Castbox and Podcast Addict, simply upgrade your account. You'll also find viewership figures for their YouTube channel if they have one.
Which podcasts are similar to Midnight Society Rejects?
These podcasts share a similar audience with Midnight Society Rejects:
1. Dateline NBC
How many episodes of Midnight Society Rejects are there?
Midnight Society Rejects launched a year ago and published 49 episodes to date. You can find more information about this podcast including rankings, audience demographics and engagement in our podcast database.
How do I contact Midnight Society Rejects?
Our systems regularly scour the web to find email addresses and social media links for this podcast. We scanned the web and collated all of the contact information that we could find in our podcast database. But in the unlikely event that you can't find what you're looking for, our concierge service lets you request our research team to source better contacts for you.
Where can I see ratings and reviews for Midnight Society Rejects?
Rephonic pulls ratings and reviews for Midnight Society Rejects from multiple sources, including Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Castbox, and Podcast Addict.
View all the reviews in one place instead of visiting each platform individually and use this information to decide if a show is worth pitching or not.
How do I access podcast episode transcripts for Midnight Society Rejects?
Rephonic provides full transcripts for episodes of Midnight Society Rejects. Search within each transcript for your keywords, whether they be topics, brands or people, and figure out if it's worth pitching as a guest or sponsor. You can even set-up alerts to get notified when your keywords are mentioned.
What guests have appeared on Midnight Society Rejects?
Recent guests on Midnight Society Rejects include:
1. Emily Hampshire
2. Nancy Kerrigan
3. Melissa Joan Hart
To view more recent guests and their details, simply upgrade your Rephonic account. You'll also get access to a typical guest profile to help you decide if the show is worth pitching.